Because of Social Media, We No Longer Live, We Perform for an Invisible Audience
A Conversation with Nicholas Carr, Author of Superbloom
In the spring of 2019, California became the stage for
one of the most remarkable phenomena in the natural world: following unusually
heavy winter rainfall, millions of wildflower seeds that had lain dormant in
the dry soil for years germinated and bloomed almost simultaneously. This was a
so-called superbloom – a rare phenomenon in which vast stretches of
normally barren land are transformed into vibrant carpets of wildflowers. Such
events are relatively uncommon and require a unique combination of specific
climatic conditions to occur.
The 2019 California superbloom was so spectacular that
it attracted enormous media attention and quickly went viral on social media.
Hundreds of thousands of people travelled to see it, and some of the
flower-covered landscapes were even visible in satellite images. In certain areas,
the influx of visitors became so overwhelming that local authorities were
forced to restrict access because of traffic congestion, safety concerns, and
fears that the flowers themselves would be damaged. In their pursuit of the
perfect photograph, many visitors wandered into the fields, trampling the
blooms and, in effect, beginning to destroy the very thing they had come to
admire.
It was precisely the 2019 superbloom that inspired
Nicholas Carr to choose the English title of Superbloom. “It seemed to me
the perfect metaphor not only for the way social media shapes human behavior,
but for social media itself,” the author told us in a conversation just days
before the Bulgarian edition was released.
We are immediately tempted to ask him what he
considers the greatest human weakness exploited by algorithms to be, and when
was the last time he forced himself to switch off a device, close a website, or
exit an app because he sensed he was beginning to succumb to the very
destructive forces he describes in his book.
“I don’t use social media all that much, but I do have
an Instagram account, and I often catch myself mindlessly scrolling through the
automatically curated and personalized stream of content,” the author says,
before continuing. “Human beings are, above all, predictable creatures. Our
drive to constantly seek out and discover new things is extraordinarily
powerful. We evolved to be highly sensitive to changes in our environment, and
social media platforms are designed to exploit precisely that instinct: to
always offer us something new, something that will instantly capture and hold
our otherwise remarkably fickle attention.”
These days, false and misleading content is becoming
increasingly dangerous: people diagnose themselves with medical conditions
online, children commit crimes under the influence of internet groups, and all
of us at times make profoundly misguided decisions simply to avoid being
different from the crowd. Many argue that we are confidently marching towards a
future in which, by blindly following self-appointed experts, we will
ultimately drive ourselves over a cliff. Is a sharp turn back still possible
before we fall? Or, cynical as it may sound, could the process we are
witnessing actually prove to be a kind of evolutionary selection?
“A sharp turn is always possible. At this stage,
however, I think it would require a countercultural movement, most likely led
by young people, aimed at rejecting these technologies altogether,” says
Nicholas Carr. “But such movements are extraordinarily difficult to predict,
much like biological evolution itself.”
What is it, though, that makes today’s digital
environment so damaging to human psychology when compared with earlier
communication technologies? Is it the instant feedback? The ease with which
even the most superficial content can win approval through likes? Or the fact
that anyone can reach vast numbers of people while saying something completely
trivial?
“More than anything else, it is the fact that we are
now continuously immersed in a digital environment thanks to technologies that
are always present and always around us: phones, tablets, computers... We have
never seen anything like this before, not with the advent of books, nor with
the invention of radio, television, or cinema,” the author says, before drawing
an intriguing conclusion: “As our social lives become increasingly shaped by
media, we ourselves begin to think and act like media personalities – as
if there is an invisible audience out there for whom we must constantly put on a
performance.”
Hyperreality brings with it a host of problems: a loss
of connection with reality, a crisis of identity, an inability to think
critically... But what about political polarization? Is it too a symptom of
hyperreality, or is it a separate phenomenon whose effects are merely amplified
by technology? And just how absurd can the issues become that drive our
societies towards ever more bitter, and sometimes even physical,
confrontations?
“Political polarization has many root causes and a
very long history,” says Nicholas Carr, before adding: “One of the central
arguments of my book is that, with the emergence of the internet and social
media, we initially believed we had created a communication system that would
bring people closer together and encourage conversation, dialogue, and mutual
understanding. But the exact opposite happened... It turns out that excessive
communication can be just as harmful as too little communication. Perhaps even
more so.”
And does the ease with which certain movements, such
as cancel culture, gain popularity today perhaps prepare the ground for even
more extreme currents in the near future? We ask the author which trends he
finds most troubling at the moment.
“The most worrying development right now is the
widespread and extraordinarily rapid adoption of artificial intelligence
capable of generating content,” he says unequivocally. “With social media, we
can already say that computers have taken over the editorial function, using
algorithms to decide which messages reach which audiences. But now machines are
also taking over the creation of the content itself. I’m not sure society is
prepared for that.”
We continue our discussion with the question of
whether the development of digital technologies and their influence on our
lives has already reached a snowball effect. Can this process realistically be
slowed down, or can we only hope to steer it in a direction that prevents it
from ultimately sweeping us away? An interesting question is how long our
civilization could actually survive without modern digital technologies, given
that even a brief Facebook outage is capable of triggering mass hysteria.
Nicholas Carr is unequivocal: “I believe society could survive without social
media. I do not, however, believe it could survive without the internet.”
The internet and digital technologies are, above all,
tools and, as such, can be used in very different ways: for creation or
destruction, for education or manipulation, to bring people together or to
deepen the alienation between them. Ultimately, it is not technology itself
that determines the direction of development, but the consciousness, values,
and intentions of those who wield it. But do the people who hold real power
have any genuine interest in limiting the influence of digital media, given
that these platforms are such convenient and effective tools for shaping and
manipulating public opinion? And to what extent can individual resistance truly
be effective?
“Individual resistance can certainly be powerful on a
personal level. I do not think, however, that its impact can extend much
further unless it grows into a mass movement,” says the author of Superbloom.
“The internet and social media are deeply woven into our social, economic, and
political systems and structures. At this stage, it is difficult for someone
simply to step aside and give them up altogether.
“There is, however, a more encouraging side to the
story. Over the past year here in the United States, we have seen courts begin
to impose serious penalties and restrictions on the companies that own social
media platforms. Politicians may not have the courage to act, but judges and
juries still do.”
Sometimes the question of which book an author wishes he had written himself
reveals more about his personality than anything else. We decide to ask
Nicholas Carr which book that would be for him.
“Probably The Making of the Atomic Bomb by Richard Rhodes,” the
author replies. “It’s an extraordinary book, one that not only tells a
remarkably compelling story, but also explains a host of highly complex
scientific and technical ideas and events in a way that is completely
accessible to a general audience.”
In Conversation with the Author: Vladimir
Tsankov
Products related to this post
Comments

